Can GOP's Old Elephant Learn New Tricks?

Deb Price
Wed, 22 Apr 2009 00:00:00 -0700
Opinion

Rumblings of change are beginning to be heard from deep inside the Republican Party.

The gay Log Cabin Republicans' recent national convention offered a tantalizing peek at a possible not-so-distant future when the Republican Party has finally — and firmly — turned the corner and embraced equality for gay Americans.

Marquee speakers were Steve Schmidt, former senior campaign strategist for 2008 Republican presidential nominee John McCain, and former New Jersey governor Christie Todd Whitman, a founder of the moderate Republican Leadership Council.
Updated: Tue Apr 21, 2009

Rumblings of change are beginning to be heard from deep inside the Republican Party.

The gay Log Cabin Republicans' recent national convention offered a tantalizing peek at a possible not-so-distant future when the Republican Party has finally — and firmly — turned the corner and embraced equality for gay Americans.

Marquee speakers were Steve Schmidt, former senior campaign strategist for 2008 Republican presidential nominee John McCain, and former New Jersey governor Christie Todd Whitman, a founder of the moderate Republican Leadership Council.

Representing the youth vote that will determine the GOP's fate was Meghan McCain, 24-year-old daughter of Sen. McCain and a contributor at TheDailyBeast.com.

Each supports marriage for same-sex couples.

That puts them firmly in the minority of today's Republicans, but definitely not of future Republicans if the party is to grow, appeal to young voters and be competitive beyond the South.

"We were crushed by the Obama campaign with voters under 30," Schmidt pointed out.

What distinguishes the youth vote, he continued, is "a greater acceptance of people who find happiness in relationships with members of the same sex." One day, a majority of Americans will follow, and he added, "sooner or later the Republican Party will catch up."

Whitman, tackling the problem of broadening the party without scaring away social conservatives, said: "It's not about saying to the Christian conservatives, 'There is no place for you.' It's about saying, 'Would you please stop saying there's no place for us?'"

Afterward, Whitman told me, "It's not going to threaten my marriage to have a gay couple marry." She wants the issue out of the party platform.

Meghan McCain was blunter: "Republicans' using Twitter and Facebook isn't going to miraculously make people think we're cool again. Breaking free from obsolete positions and providing real solutions that don't divide our nation further will."

It'd be easy to dismiss the trio of speakers as preaching to choir, but encouraging rumblings are coming from elsewhere, as well.

Gay Republicans point with pride to the fact that eight Republicans in the Vermont legislature helped override the governor's veto of gay marriage.

Meanwhile, gay Iowans are set to begin marrying on April 27, thanks to a ruling written by a Republican appointee. A University of Iowa Hawkeye Poll conducted just before the April 3 unanimous Iowa Supreme Court ruling for gay marriage found that 58 percent of Iowans ages 18 to 29 favor gay marriage, 17 percent prefer civil unions, and only 16 percent oppose both.

That means fewer than one out of five favors the official Republican position.

Contrast that with Iowans 65 or older: 18 percent favor gay marriage, 31 percent civil unions, and 42 percent neither.

If you were running a company that hopes to still be around in 20 years, which customers would you appeal to?

That question is being asked in elite Republican circles. In a survey of its Republican political insiders, National Journal magazine found in its most recent issue that only 50 percent thinks their party should oppose gay marriage, while 8 percent thinks the party should embrace it, and 37 percent says it should steer clear of the issue.

Speaking freely behind the cloak of anonymity, one Republican insider said: "Perception of complete hostility to all gay rights is killing the GOP among voters under 29. Evolve or perish, Republicans."

Another said: "Among younger voters this has become a threshold issue about tolerance. And opposition is now hurting Republicans with swing voters more than it helps them with their base."

A growing number of Republican thinkers are concluding that their party's future hinges on finding a way to comfortably embrace gay rights.